Prove that electron cannot reside inside the nucleus of an atom.
Q.3 (b) Prove that electron cannot reside inside the nucleus of an atom.
Q.3 (b) Prove that electron cannot reside inside the nucleus of an atom.
Best answer
Using Heisenberg's uncertainty principle: \(\Delta x\,\Delta p\ge\dfrac{\hbar}{2}=\dfrac{h}{4\pi}\)
The diameter of a nucleus is about \(10^{-14}\) m. If an electron were confined inside it, the maximum uncertainty in its position would be \(\Delta x=10^{-14}\) m.
\[ \Delta p\ge\frac{h}{4\pi\Delta x}=\frac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{4\pi\times10^{-14}}=5.28\times10^{-21}\ \text{kg m/s} \]
The momentum itself must be at least of the order of its uncertainty, so \(p\approx5.28\times10^{-21}\) kg m/s.
Since \(pc\gg m_0c^2\) (\(pc\approx1.6\times10^{-12}\) J, while \(m_0c^2=8.2\times10^{-14}\) J), the electron would be relativistic, so \(E\approx pc\):
\[ E\approx pc=5.28\times10^{-21}\times3\times10^8=1.58\times10^{-12}\ \text{J}=\frac{1.58\times10^{-12}}{1.6\times10^{-13}}\ \text{MeV}\approx9.9\ \text{MeV} \]
(Using \(\Delta x\Delta p\ge\hbar\) instead gives about 20 MeV. The conclusion is the same.)
Conclusion: An electron inside the nucleus would need an energy of about 10 to 20 MeV. Experiments show that electrons emitted from nuclei (β-particles) have energies of only about 2 to 4 MeV, and electrons in atoms have energies of only a few eV to keV. Hence electrons cannot reside inside the nucleus.
Log in or create a free account to answer this question.