2 answers
Best answer
Let the equilibrium of the test charge be stable. If a test charge is in equilibrium and displaced from its position in any direction, then it experiences a restoring force towards a null point, where the electric field is zero. All the field lines near the null point are directed inwards towards the null point. There is a net inward flux of electric field through a closed surface around the null point. According to Gauss’s law, the flux of electric field through a surface, which is not enclosing any charge, is zero. Hence, the equilibrium of the test charge can be stable.
Was this answer helpful?
Thanks for the feedback.
Sign up free to save answers and ask your own doubts
Answer: At a null point the equilibrium cannot be stable, because stability would need a net inward flux through a surface that encloses no charge, which Gauss's law forbids.
Proof by contradiction:
- Suppose the test charge at the null point P (where \(E = 0\)) were in stable equilibrium.
- Then, if it is displaced slightly in any direction, it must feel a restoring force back towards P. So the electric field at every point close to P must point towards P.
- Draw a small closed surface around P. The field crosses this surface inwards everywhere, so the net electric flux through it is non-zero (inward).
- But this small surface encloses no charge (P is an empty point of the field), so by Gauss's law the net flux must be \(\phi = q_{\text{enc}}/\varepsilon_0 = 0\).
Steps 3 and 4 contradict each other, so the assumption is false. The equilibrium of the test charge at a null point is necessarily unstable: it can be restoring in some directions but never in all directions.
Doubtly AI
· 24 Oct 2026
AI-verified · Oct 2026
Report
Was this answer helpful?
Thanks for the feedback.
Sign up free to save answers and ask your own doubts
Your answer
Log in or create a free account to answer this question.