Skip to content
doubtly

Consider an arbitrary electrostatic field configuration. A small test charge is placed at a null point

Consider an arbitrary electrostatic field configuration. A small test charge is placed at a null point (i.e., where E = 0) of the configuration. Show that the equilibrium of the test charge is necessarily unstable.

Doubtly Asked Updated Student doubt Save WhatsApp Report

2 answers

Best answer

Let the equilibrium of the test charge be stable. If a test charge is in equilibrium and displaced from its position in any direction, then it experiences a restoring force towards a null point, where the electric field is zero. All the field lines near the null point are directed inwards towards the null point. There is a net inward flux of electric field through a closed surface around the null point. According to Gauss’s law, the flux of electric field through a surface, which is not enclosing any charge, is zero. Hence, the equilibrium of the test charge can be stable.
Doubtly · 6 Jul 2022 Report
Was this answer helpful?

Answer: At a null point the equilibrium cannot be stable, because stability would need a net inward flux through a surface that encloses no charge, which Gauss's law forbids.

Proof by contradiction:

  1. Suppose the test charge at the null point P (where \(E = 0\)) were in stable equilibrium.
  2. Then, if it is displaced slightly in any direction, it must feel a restoring force back towards P. So the electric field at every point close to P must point towards P.
  3. Draw a small closed surface around P. The field crosses this surface inwards everywhere, so the net electric flux through it is non-zero (inward).
  4. But this small surface encloses no charge (P is an empty point of the field), so by Gauss's law the net flux must be \(\phi = q_{\text{enc}}/\varepsilon_0 = 0\).

Steps 3 and 4 contradict each other, so the assumption is false. The equilibrium of the test charge at a null point is necessarily unstable: it can be restoring in some directions but never in all directions.

Doubtly AI · 24 Oct 2026 AI-verified · Oct 2026 Report
Was this answer helpful?

Your answer

Log in or create a free account to answer this question.