2 answers
Answer: The irony in 'An Astrologer's Day' is that a man who knows nothing about astrology speaks the complete truth about his client, because the client is the very man he himself once stabbed and left for dead.
Irony is a contrast between what is expected and what actually happens, or between what seems and what is.
Ironic elements in the story:
- The astrologer has no real knowledge of the stars. He works only by shrewd guesswork, yet his 'predictions' to the stranger turn out to be exactly true.
- His 'supernatural knowledge' is really personal memory: he recognises the stranger (Guru Nayak) as the man he stabbed and pushed into a well in his village after a drunken quarrel. He seems to read the stars but is actually describing his own crime.
- Guru Nayak has come in search of his attacker, and the attacker is sitting right in front of him, telling his fortune.
- The astrologer tells Guru Nayak that his enemy is dead, crushed under a lorry, and advises him to go home and never travel south again. The only 'lie' in the reading is the one that protects the astrologer himself.
- The astrologer, who escaped from his village because he thought he had killed a man, learns that night that Guru Nayak is alive. He feels relieved of a great burden, and even earns money from the man he wronged.
Thus the fake fortune-teller's words come true only because they are about himself, which is the central irony of the story.
Answer: The irony is that the astrologer, who has no real knowledge of the stars, tells Guru Nayak his past exactly, not by any supernatural power but because he himself was the man who had stabbed him.
Irony is a contrast between what appears or is expected and what really is. In "An Astrologer's Day" it works like this:
- The astrologer is a fraud. He "knew no more of what was going to happen to others than he knew what was going to happen to himself the next minute"; he lives on shrewd guesswork.
- Guru Nayak challenges him. When the match flares, the astrologer recognises him as the man he stabbed and pushed into a well years ago in his village.
- He then "predicts" that the man was stabbed, pushed into a well and left for dead, and even tells him his name. Guru Nayak is amazed at this "supernatural knowledge", though it is simply the astrologer's own memory of his crime.
- He tells Guru Nayak that his attacker died four months ago in a far-off town and that he should go home and never travel south again. The man searching for revenge pays the very person he is looking for and leaves satisfied.
- The only time the astrologer speaks the full truth is about himself, and he uses it to protect himself.
So the "prophecy" turns out true only by this coincidence, which is the central irony of the story.
Your answer
Log in or create a free account to answer this question.