Skip to content
doubtly

2 answers

Answer: The astrologer had no knowledge of astrology, but he understood people very well; by observing and listening to them he quickly guessed their troubles and said what pleased them.

  • He knew no more about the future than his clients did, yet he succeeded by study, practice and shrewd guesswork.
  • He had a working analysis of mankind's troubles: marriage, money and the tangles of human relationships.
  • Long practice had sharpened his perception, so within five minutes he understood what was wrong with a client.
  • He let the client speak first for at least ten minutes, which gave him enough material for a dozen answers and much advice.
  • He then said general things that applied to almost everyone, such as 'In many ways you are not getting the fullest results for your efforts', which pleased and astonished his clients.
  • He also chose his place and appearance well: the turban, sacred ash and the glow in his eyes made people trust him.
  • His sharpest judgement is seen with the stranger: he recognised Guru Nayak at once, haggled for a rupee, and calmly told him that his enemy was dead and he should go home, thus saving his own life.
Doubtly · 20 Jul 2022 Report
Was this answer helpful?

Answer: The astrologer had no knowledge of astrology, but long practice had made him an expert at reading people: he let clients talk first, understood their troubles quickly and said things that suited almost everyone.

Details from the story that show this:

  • "He had a working analysis of mankind's troubles: marriage, money, and the tangles of human ties." He knew the common worries of ordinary people.
  • "Long practice had sharpened his perception. Within five minutes he understood what was wrong."
  • He never opened his mouth until the client had spoken for at least ten minutes, which gave him enough material for a dozen answers and pieces of advice.
  • He used general statements that most people accept about themselves, such as "In many ways you are not getting the fullest results for your efforts", with which nine out of ten agreed.
  • With Guru Nayak he quickly read the danger, handled him calmly and sent him away satisfied.

So he earned his living by "study, practice and shrewd guesswork", not by the stars, and that is why he is called a shrewd judge of character.

Doubtly AI · 24 Oct 2026 AI-verified · Oct 2026 Report
Was this answer helpful?

Your answer

Log in or create a free account to answer this question.